| 528 | MJ Hilton | Lancashire v Scotland | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1956 |
| 486 | GW Youngson | Scotland v Ireland | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1954 |
| 474 | V Broderick | Northamptonshire v Scotland | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1951 |
| 450 | JH Wardle | Yorkshire v Scotland | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1952 |
| 450 | SSJ Huey | Ireland v Scotland | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1960 |
| 434 | TB Burtt | New Zealanders v Scotland | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1949 |
| 414 | M Kerrigan | Scotland v Ireland | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1960 |
| 412 | JM Allan | Scotland v Ireland | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1954 |
| 408 | JD Henderson | Scotland v Yorkshire | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1950 |
| 408 | JM Allan | Scotland v Indians | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1959 |
| 396 | JD Monteith | Ireland v Scotland | Titwood, Glasgow | 1984 |
| 390 | E Smith | Derbyshire v Scotland | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1955 |
| 385 | GW Youngson | Scotland v Ireland | North Inch, Perth | 1950 |
| 384 | JM Allan | Scotland v Pakistanis | Philiphaugh, Selkirk | 1971 |
| 378 | M Kerrigan | Scotland v Lancashire | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1956 |
| 365 | GW Youngson | Scotland v Ireland | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1948 |
| 364 | TH Dixon | Ireland v Scotland | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1928 |
| 362 | M Kerrigan | Scotland v Derbyshire | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1955 |
| 361 | RM Haq | Scotland v Ireland | Mannofield Park, Aberdeen | 2009 |
| 360 | JC Boucher | Ireland v Scotland | North Inch, Perth | 1950 |
| 348 | WC Pemberton | Ireland v Scotland | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1928 |
| 348 | SC Corlett | Ireland v Scotland | Titwood, Glasgow | 1984 |
| 348 | HA Varaiya | Kenya v Scotland | Mannofield Park, Aberdeen | 2013 |
| 347 | R Wood | Yorkshire v Scotland | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1952 |
| 344 | GW Youngson | Scotland v Worcestershire | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1955 |
| 342 | WL Fraser | Scotland v Ireland | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1913 |
| 342 | JD Monteith | Ireland v Scotland | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1968 |
| 341 | JW Govan | Scotland v Ireland | Nunholm, Dumfries | 1988 |
| 339 | R Tattersall | Lancashire v Scotland | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1956 |
| 336 | WP Howell | Australians v Scotland | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1905 |
| 336 | JAW Kirk | Scotland v Ireland | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1922 |