| 13-74 | (6-37, 7-37) | D Buchanan | Scotland v Marylebone Cricket Club | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1874 |
| 13-174 | (6-88, 7-86) | O Henry | Scotland v Ireland | Castle Avenue, Dublin | 1989 |
| 12-54 | (4-22, 8-32) | R Scott | Scotland v Parsees | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1886 |
| 12-78 | (7-39, 5-39) | W Nichol | Scotland v Ireland | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1948 |
| 12-182 | (7-140, 5-42) | EG Dennett | Scotland v GL Jessop's XI | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1903 |
| 11-51 | (6-33, 5-18) | D Livingstone | Scotland v Ireland | College Park, Dublin | 1957 |
| 11-65 | (6-56, 5-9) | WDF Dow | Scotland v Ireland | Sydney Parade, Dublin | 1965 |
| 11-72 | (8-41, 3-31) | DL Addison Smith | Scotland v Notts Amateurs | Bonville Park, Cupar | 1896 |
| 11-77 | (8-34, 3-43) | GF Goddard | Scotland v Ireland | Glenpark, Greenock | 1972 |
| 11-97 | (5-72, 6-25) | D Buchanan | Scotland v Surrey Club | Kennington Oval, Kennington | 1865 |
| 11-100 | (7-56, 4-44) | RV Webster | Scotland v Marylebone Cricket Club | Glenpark, Greenock | 1961 |
| 11-107 | (5-31, 6-76) | JH Bruce-Lockhart | Scotland v Ireland | College Park, Dublin | 1910 |
| 11-119 | (7-42, 4-77) | GW Youngson | Scotland v Ireland | North Inch, Perth | 1950 |
| 11-123 | (7-54, 4-69) | JM Allan | Scotland v Pakistanis | Philiphaugh, Selkirk | 1971 |
| 11-146 | (7-86, 4-60) | W Ringrose | Scotland v Nottinghamshire | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1908 |
| 11-175 | (5-88, 6-87) | AD Baxter | Scotland v South Americans | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1932 |
| 11-210 | (8-134, 3-76) | GF Goddard | Scotland v Marylebone Cricket Club | Titwood, Glasgow | 1973 |
| 10-103 | (4-60, 6-43) | G Thornton | Gentlemen of Scotland v Gentlemen of Canada | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1887 |
| 10-126 | (4-71, 6-55) | RW Sievwright | Scotland v Oxford University | The University Parks, Oxford | 1913 |
| 10-131 | (7-84, 3-47) | M Kerrigan | Scotland v Ireland | Whitehaugh Oval, Paisley | 1960 |
| 10-? | (4-?, 6-?) | WJ Laidlay | Scotland v Free Foresters | The Cricket Ground, Rugby | 1874 |
| 9-72 | (6-49, 3-23) | DS Hiddleston | Scotland v Ireland | College Park, Dublin | 1931 |
| 9-72 | (4-25, 5-47) | Asim Butt | Scotland v Ireland | Castle Avenue, Dublin | 2004 |
| 9-79 | (5-33, 4-46) | WK Laidlaw | Scotland v Marylebone Cricket Club | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1939 |
| 9-79 | (6-58, 3-21) | F Robertson | Scotland v Ireland | Ormeau, Belfast | 1971 |
| 9-88 | (4-39, 5-49) | GF Goddard | Scotland v Netherlands | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1980 |
| 9-92 | (4-38, 5-54) | JW Govan | Scotland v Ireland | Nunholm, Dumfries | 1988 |
| 9-106 | (5-45, 4-61) | JAR Blain | Scotland v Namibia | Wanderers Cricket Ground, Windhoek | 2007/08 |
| 9-109 | (6-47, 3-62) | RV Webster | Scotland v Middlesex | Raeburn Place, Edinburgh | 1962 |
| 9-111 | (4-57, 5-54) | SJ Thomson | Scotland v Ireland | Hamilton Crescent, Glasgow | 1938 |
| 9-118 | (4-34, 5-84) | RW Sievwright | Scotland v Ireland | College Park, Dublin | 1929 |
| 9-118 | (5-30, 4-88) | RM Haq | Scotland v Ireland | Mannofield Park, Aberdeen | 2009 |
| 9-128 | (6-57, 3-71) | CL Parfitt | Scotland v Marylebone Cricket Club | Lord's Cricket Ground, St John's Wood | 1990 |
| 9-156 | (6-70, 3-86) | JW Govan | Scotland v Ireland | Forthill, Dundee | 1992 |
| 9-181 | (5-79, 4-102) | AD Baxter | Scotland v Ireland | Glenpark, Greenock | 1932 |