| 4 | RG Broadbent | Scotland v Worcestershire | 1955 | f20848 |
| 4 | G Dews | Scotland v Worcestershire | 1955 | f20848 |
| 3 | RH Catterall | Scotland v South Africans | 1924 | f10859 |
| 3 | HG Vivian | Scotland v New Zealanders | 1937 | f15857 |
| 3 | N Gallichan | Scotland v New Zealanders | 1937 | f15857 |
| 3 | FM Quinn | Scotland v Ireland | 1948 | f18053 |
| 3 | HF Sheppard | Yorkshire v Scotland | 1952 | f19637 |
| 3 | EI Lester | Scotland v Yorkshire | 1952 | f19637 |
| 3 | GH Padgett | Scotland v Yorkshire | 1952 | f19637 |
| 3 | HB Cave | Scotland v New Zealanders | 1958 | f22322 |
| 3 | ER Thompson | Marylebone Cricket Club v Scotland | 1967 | f26784 |