misc69692	Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs v United South of England Eleven
	United South of England Eleven matches 1872
Venue	Craigmount Park, Edinburgh on 23rd, 24th, 25th May 1872 (3-day match)
Balls per over	4
Players	Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs: 22; United South of England Eleven: 11
Toss	Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs won the toss and decided to bat
Result	Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs won by 64 runs
Umpires	H Killick, D Willoughby
Close of play day 1	United South of England Eleven (1) 22/2 (Jupp 10*)
Close of play day 2	Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs (2) 99/7 (Cotterill 83*, Buchanan 5*)

---

Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs first innings		Runs	Balls	Mins	4s	6s
J Sanderson	b Southerton	0
WW Smith	st Pooley b Southerton	3
RS Stewart	c Pooley b Lillywhite	4
WJ Laidlay	c GF Grace b Southerton	0
S Wright	c Pooley b Lillywhite	0
J Speid	st Pooley b Southerton	3
G Campbell	c GF Grace b Southerton	0
AR Duncan	b Southerton	0
JM Cotterill	c and b Southerton	14
JB Richardson	c R Humphrey b Southerton	8
W St Clair Grant	c Jupp b Lillywhite	1
GF Rayner	c GF Grace b Southerton	3
JLH McFarlane	c Southerton b Lillywhite	2
J Craig	c T Humphrey b Southerton	2
+W Cunningham	c Southerton b Lillywhite	20
A Buchanan	b Southerton	4
ADR Thomson	c Charlwood b Lillywhite	0
C Hayman	b Lillywhite	0
*D MacDonald	not out	7
WE Anderson	c Pooley b Southerton	3
R Evans	b Southerton	0
D Crole	c WG Grace b Southerton	0
Extras	(3 b)	3
Total	(all out, 76.1 overs)	77
Fall of wickets:
1-0, 2-5, 3-5, 4-5, 5-12, 6-12, 7-12, 8-12, 9-27, 10-28, 11-34, 12-40, 13-?, 14-56, 15-63, 16-67, 17-67, 18-67, 19-75, 20-77, 21-77 (76.1 ov)

United South of England Eleven bowling	Overs	Mdns	Runs	Wkts	Wides	No-Balls
Southerton	38.1	15	48	14	-	-
Lillywhite	38	23	26	7	-	-

---

United South of England Eleven first innings		Runs	Balls	Mins	4s	6s
WG Grace	c Richardson b Campbell	8
H Jupp	run out (Crole)	14
R Humphrey	b St Clair Grant	1
GF Grace	c Stewart b Campbell	4
HRJ Charlwood	b Campbell	19
+EW Pooley	run out	1
T Humphrey	c Stewart b Campbell	1
J Lillywhite	c Buchanan b St Clair Grant	2
J Phillips	c Sanderson b St Clair Grant	2
G Griffith	c Stewart b St Clair Grant	3
J Southerton	not out	0
Extras	(1 b, 1 lb, 3 w)	5
Total	(all out, 76.1 overs)	60
Fall of wickets:
1-15, 2-22, 3-27, 4-32, 5-40, 6-41, 7-?, 8-57, 9-58, 10-60 (76.1 ov)

Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs bowling	Overs	Mdns	Runs	Wkts	Wides	No-Balls
St Clair Grant	38.1	25	16	4	-	-
Campbell	38	16	39	4	-	-

---

Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs second innings		Runs	Balls	Mins	4s	6s
*D MacDonald	st Pooley b Southerton	1
WW Smith	b Lillywhite	8
RS Stewart	b Southerton	0
J Speid	b Southerton	0
JM Cotterill	c GF Grace b Southerton	95
J Sanderson	st Pooley b Southerton	0
S Wright	b Southerton	2
WJ Laidlay	b Southerton	0
A Buchanan	b Southerton	5
JLH McFarlane	b Southerton	8
GF Rayner	b Southerton	0
W St Clair Grant	b WG Grace	9
AR Duncan	c GF Grace b WG Grace	1
G Campbell	c WG Grace b Southerton	9
ADR Thomson	c and b WG Grace	3
JB Richardson	b Southerton	1
C Hayman	b Southerton	0
J Craig	b WG Grace	1
+W Cunningham	b Southerton	1
D Crole	hit wkt b Southerton	1
WE Anderson	c R Humphrey b WG Grace	6
[unknown]	not out	0
Extras	(3 b)	3
Total	(all out, 128.2 overs)	154
Fall of wickets:
1-?, 2-?, 3-?, 4-?, 5-?, 6-?, 7-61, 8-103, 9-118, 10-119, 11-124, 12-129, 13-131, 14-137, 15-?, 16-143, 17-?, 18-?, 19-147, 20-151, 21-154 (128.2 ov)

United South of England Eleven bowling	Overs	Mdns	Runs	Wkts	Wides	No-Balls
Southerton	64.2	30	67	15	-	-
Lillywhite	19	10	19	1	-	-
WG Grace	30	14	30	5	-	-
GF Grace	10	4	21	0	-	-
Griffith	5	1	14	0	-	-

---

United South of England Eleven second innings		Runs	Balls	Mins	4s	6s
WG Grace	c Richardson b Laidlay	17
H Jupp	c Laidlay b St Clair Grant	0
R Humphrey	b St Clair Grant	0
GF Grace	b Laidlay	2
HRJ Charlwood	run out	35
+EW Pooley	c and b St Clair Grant	25
T Humphrey	b Cotterill	6
J Lillywhite	b Laidlay	11
J Phillips	run out (Craig)	5
G Griffith	not out	2
J Southerton	c Stewart b Laidlay	2
Extras	(1 b, 1 lb)	2
Total	(all out, 95.1 overs)	107
Fall of wickets:
1-3, 2-15, 3-?, 4-19, 5-67, 6-75, 7-86, 8-100, 9-?, 10-107 (95.1 ov)

Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs bowling	Overs	Mdns	Runs	Wkts	Wides	No-Balls
St Clair Grant	38	16	40	3	-	-
Laidlay	26.1	10	51	4	-	-
Campbell	12	7	8	0	-	-
Cotterill	9	6	4	1	-	-
Buchanan	10	9	2	0	-	-

---

W Cunningham began the match as wicketkeeper for Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs, but was injured while keeping on the first day. WL Laidlay kept wicket on the second day.
The Scotsman newspaper names the home side as 'XXII Gentlemen of Edinburgh'
R Evans, who batted in the Carlton and Edinburgh Clubs' first innings, is referred to in The Scotsman's scorecard as 'Substitute'. In the second innings, the substitute who completed their batting order was not Evans, but a player named as 'Mr Hill'.