| Main FC | Yorkshire (1868) |
| Miscellaneous | Sheffield (1864-1869) |
| Gentlemen of Sheffield (1868) | |
| Birmingham (1874-1877) | |
| Staffordshire (1877-1882) | |
| Colts of England (1878) | |
| Players of Scotland (1879) | |
| Port Elizabeth (1884/85-1888/89) | |
| Eastern Province (1891/92) |