| Main FC | Surrey (1872) |
| Miscellaneous | Wiltshire (1867) |
| | Gentlemen of Scotland (1870) |
| | Gentlemen of Surrey (1872) |
| | Surrey (1873) |
| | Crystal Palace (1873) |
| | Surrey Club (1874) |
| | Northumberland (1875-1881) |
| | Gentlemen of Northumberland (1877-1884) |
| | Newcastle upon Tyne (1878-1887) |
| | Gentlemen (1878) |
| | Sunderland (1878) |
| | Chiswick and Turnham Green (1879) |
| | Newcastle (1879) |
| | Northumberland Club (1880-1890) |
| | Northumberland (1881-1892) |
| | Surrey Club and Ground (1882) |
| | Northumberland XI (1887) |
| | Newcastle and District (1889) |
| | West Northumberland (1893) |
| | FGH Clayton's XI (1897) |