| 4 | CEB Rice | Derbyshire v Nottinghamshire | 1985 | a4416 |
| 4 | RA Pick | Kent v Nottinghamshire | 1987 | a5202 |
| 4 | CC Lewis | Worcestershire v Nottinghamshire | 1992 | a7622 |
| 4 | RJ Hamilton-Brown | Nottinghamshire v Sussex | 2013 | a22702 |
| 4 | CR Woakes | Pakistan v England | 2019 | a27401 |
| 4 | M Labuschagne | England v Australia | 2024 | a31126 |
| 3 | M Hill | Wiltshire v Nottinghamshire | 1965 | a45 |
| 3 | RA White | Kent v Nottinghamshire | 1969 | a192 |
| 3 | B Stead | Northamptonshire v Nottinghamshire | 1970 | a300 |
| 3 | CJR Black | Nottinghamshire v Middlesex | 1973 | a920 |
| 3 | PH Edmonds | Nottinghamshire v Middlesex | 1975 | a1489 |
| 3 | CEB Rice | Minor Counties East v Nottinghamshire | 1976 | a1618 |
| 3 | GW Johnson | Nottinghamshire v Kent | 1976 | a1654 |
| 3 | DW Randall | Surrey v Nottinghamshire | 1976 | a1758 |
| 3 | MH Denness | Nottinghamshire v Essex | 1977 | a1928 |
| 3 | K Saxelby | Yorkshire v Nottinghamshire | 1981 | a3042 |
| 3 | RJ Hadlee | Leicestershire v Nottinghamshire | 1987 | a5270 |
| 3 | EE Hemmings | Hampshire v Nottinghamshire | 1987 | a5368 |
| 3 | FD Stephenson | Surrey v Nottinghamshire | 1988 | a5797 |
| 3 | CEL Ambrose | Nottinghamshire v Northamptonshire | 1990 | a6546 |
| 3 | PR Pollard | Somerset v Nottinghamshire | 1993 | a8034 |
| 3 | RG Twose | Nottinghamshire v Warwickshire | 1995 | a9178 |
| 3 | JER Gallian | Somerset v Nottinghamshire | 1998 | a11286 |
| 3 | DP Ostler | Nottinghamshire v Warwickshire | 2001 | a13501 |
| 3 | R Clarke | Zimbabwe v England | 2003 | a15186 |
| 3 | Hasan Adnan | Nottinghamshire v Derbyshire | 2004 | a15971 |
| 3 | JER Gallian | Durham v Nottinghamshire | 2006 | a17482 |
| 3 | SP Fleming | Sussex v Nottinghamshire | 2006 | a17619 |
| 3 | AD Hales | Scotland v Nottinghamshire | 2010 | a20699 |
| 3 | DJ Hussey | Warwickshire v Nottinghamshire | 2010 | a20704 |
| 3 | MH Wessels | Durham v Nottinghamshire | 2012 | a22097 |
| 3 | SR Patel | Netherlands v Nottinghamshire | 2013 | a22643 |
| 3 | SJ Mullaney | Warwickshire v Nottinghamshire | 2013 | a22688 |
| 3 | SR Patel | Northamptonshire v Nottinghamshire | 2013 | a22754 |
| 3 | SR Patel | Northamptonshire v Nottinghamshire | 2016 | a24752 |
| 3 | CR Woakes | Sri Lanka v England | 2016 | a24803 |
| 3 | EG Barnard | Nottinghamshire v Worcestershire | 2016 | a24857 |
| 3 | PD Collingwood | Nottinghamshire v Durham | 2017 | a25568 |