| 4 | PD Collingwood | Leicestershire v Durham | 2011 | a21461 |
| 3 | RJ Bailey | Durham v Northamptonshire | 1996 | a9824 |
| 3 | SJE Brown | Northamptonshire v Durham | 1997 | a10456 |
| 3 | RT Ponting | Bangladesh v Australia | 1999 | a11946 |
| 3 | TR Ward | Durham v Leicestershire | 2002 | a14414 |
| 3 | MP Maynard | Durham v Glamorgan | 2002 | a14454 |
| 3 | CD Hopkinson | Durham v Sussex | 2003 | a15268 |
| 3 | AG Botha | Durham v Derbyshire | 2007 | a18198 |
| 3 | GJ Muchall | Middlesex v Durham | 2007 | a18304 |
| 3 | MJ Di Venuto | Scotland v Durham | 2008 | a19004 |
| 3 | WR Smith | Derbyshire v Durham | 2008 | a19008 |
| 3 | GJ Muchall | Bangladesh A v Durham | 2008 | a19087 |
| 3 | AB McDonald | Durham v Leicestershire | 2010 | a20592 |
| 3 | C Overton | Durham v Somerset | 2012 | a21970 |
| 3 | VS Solanki | Durham v Surrey | 2013 | a22800 |
| 3 | BT Foakes | Durham v Surrey | 2015 | a24178 |
| 3 | LRPL Taylor | Durham v Nottinghamshire | 2018 | a26468 |
| 3 | JTA Burnham | Northamptonshire v Durham | 2019 | a27266 |
| 3 | BA Raine | Leicestershire v Durham | 2019 | a27277 |
| 3 | F du Plessis | Sri Lanka v South Africa | 2019 | a27437 |