| 4 | GT Branston | Scotland v Nottinghamshire | 1908 | f7432 |
| 3 | FJ Laver | Scotland v Australians | 1905 | f6685 |
| 3 | J Greive | Ireland v Scotland | 1920 | f9700 |
| 3 | WW Anderson | Middlesex v Scotland | 1923 | f10670 |
| 3 | DB Carr | Scotland v Derbyshire | 1955 | f21041 |
| 3 | DC Morgan | Scotland v Derbyshire | 1955 | f21041 |
| 3 | RE Marshall | Scotland v Marylebone Cricket Club | 1959 | f22782 |
| 3 | D Barr | Marylebone Cricket Club v Scotland | 1959 | f22782 |
| 3 | PL Mommsen | Australia A v Scotland | 2013 | f54873 |