| 55 | SM Sharif | 2011-2025 |
| 48 | RD Berrington | 2008-2025 |
| 46 | CM Wright | 1998-2007 |
| 43 | RM Haq | 2002-2014/15 |
| 35 | JD Nel | 2004-2010 |
| 31 | MRJ Watt | 2015-2025 |
| 25 | PJC Hoffmann | 2003-2007 |
| 25 | PL Mommsen | 2011-2017 |
| 25 | CS MacLeod | 2008-2022 |
| 24 | J Brown | 1953-1973 |
| 24 | JAR Blain | 1996-2008/09 |
| 24 | RT Lyons | 2005-2010 |
| 24 | MA Leask | 2013/14-2025 |
| 23 | JM Allan | 1958-1972 |
| 21 | GF Goddard | 1961-1983 |
| 21 | JE Ker | 1977-1987 |
| 21 | KLP Sheridan | 1991/92-2001 |
| 21 | IM Stanger | 1993-2005 |
| 21 | JG Williamson | 1994-2005 |
| 20 | MH Cross | 2013/14-2025 |
| 19 | G Salmond | 1990-2000 |
| 19 | CJO Smith | 1999-2008 |
| 19 | AC Evans | 2010-2021/22 |
| 18 | NFI McCallum | 2002-2010/11 |
| 18 | HG Munsey | 2015-2025 |
| 17 | GW Youngson | 1947-1955 |
| 17 | DR Lockhart | 1996-2010 |
| 17 | DF Watts | 2001-2011/12 |
| 17 | KJ Coetzer | 2003-2022/23 |
| 17 | JH Davey | 2011-2022/23 |
| 17 | CN Greaves | 2021/22-2025 |
The list shows the top 31