| Main FC | Surrey (1854-1857) |
| | Middlesex (1861) |
| | New South Wales (1862/63-1869/70) |
| Other FC | The World (1861/62) |
| Miscellaneous | Scotland (1849-1858) |
| | Carlisle (1850) |
| | Phoenix (1852-1860) |
| | Players of Dublin (1853-1861) |
| | United Ireland Eleven (1856-1861) |
| | Ireland (1856-1861) |
| | Vice Regal Lodge (1856) |
| | Coolattin (1856) |
| | Military and Civil Club (1857) |
| | Clydesdale (1859-1866) |
| | Caledonian Club (1860-1861) |
| | Officers of Ireland (1861) |
| | HH Stephenson's XI (1861/62) |
| | Albert Cricket Club (1863/64-1864/65) |
| | New South Wales (1863/64-1873/74) |
| | The World (1866/67) |
| | Manly Beach (1866/67) |
| | Australian Aboriginals (1866/67-1868/69) |
| | Bathurst (1873/74) |
| | New South Wales and Victoria (1873/74) |
| | Newcastle (1877/78-1883/84) |
| | Northern Districts of New South Wales (1880/81) |