| Main FC | Oxford University (1883) |
| Miscellaneous | Loretto School (1879-1881) |
| Gentlemen of Loretto School (1879) | |
| Roxburghshire (1881) | |
| LML Owen's XI (1882) | |
| Oxford University Freshmen (1882) | |
| MC Kemp's XI (1883) | |
| Oxford University (1883) | |
| Durham (1883-1893) | |
| Oxford University Satellites (1884) | |
| Fettesian Lorettonians (1884-1892) | |
| Hovingham Hall (1886) | |
| Newcastle upon Tyne (1887) | |
| Edinburgh (1888) | |
| Gentlemen of Durham (1890-1891) | |
| SH Wood's XI (1894-1895) |