| Main FC | Oxford University (1876-1878) |
| Miscellaneous | Rugby School (1873-1875) |
| Kincardineshire (1875-1878) | |
| Oxford University Freshmen (1876) | |
| Oxford University Undergraduates (1876-1879) | |
| Aberdeenshire (1876) | |
| Oxford University (1877-1879) | |
| Harlequins (1878) | |
| A Pearson's XI (1879) | |
| Gentlemen of Scotland (1880) | |
| Scotland (1882-1886) | |
| Edinburgh (1884-1889) | |
| Grange (1884-1894) | |
| Fettesian Lorettonians (1884-1885) | |
| Dumfriesshire (1911) |