| Main FC | Nottinghamshire (1869-1871) |
| | Lancashire (1872-1880) |
| Other FC | All England Eleven (1869-1878) |
| | North (1869-1873) |
| | R Daft's XI (1870) |
| | Players (1878) |
| Miscellaneous | Nottingham Commercial Club (1867-1868) |
| | Arnold (1867) |
| | Nottinghamshire Colts (1868) |
| | Thomas Walker's Team (1868) |
| | York (1868) |
| | Bolton (1868-1877) |
| | Dudley (1868-1872) |
| | Mansfield (1868) |
| | Somercotes (1868) |
| | Stoke-on-Trent (1868) |
| | United England Eleven (1868) |
| | Worcestershire (1868) |
| | Scarborough (1868) |
| | Chelmsford (1868) |
| | Edinburgh (1869) |
| | Radcliffe-on-Trent (1869) |
| | Staveley (1869) |
| | All England Eleven (1869-1874) |
| | Northamptonshire (1869) |
| | Nottinghamshire (1869-1870) |
| | Broughton (1870) |
| | Grantham (1870) |
| | Lancashire Residents (1870) |
| | South of Lancashire (1872) |
| | An Eleven (1872) |
| | United North of England Eleven (1872-1879) |
| | Lancashire (1874-1879) |
| | Eaton Park (1875) |
| | Lancashire XI (1876-1879) |
| | Saltaire (1876) |
| | United South of England Eleven (1879) |
| | Castleton (1879-1881) |
| | Lancashire Professionals (1879) |