| Main FC | Gloucestershire (1872-1874) |
| | Oxford University (1874-1875) |
| Miscellaneous | HG Tylecote's XI (1870) |
| | Clifton College (1871-1873) |
| | FJ Bruce's XI (1874) |
| | Oxford University Freshmen (1874) |
| | Oxford University (1874-1875) |
| | Oxford and Cambridge Universities (1874) |
| | F Townsend's XI (1874) |
| | Etceteras (1875) |
| | Harlequins (1875) |
| | Edinburgh (1877-1878) |
| | Roxburghshire (1877) |
| | Cumberland (1878) |
| | Newcastle upon Tyne (1880) |
| | Scotland (1880) |
| | Esher (1881-1884) |
| | Northumberland (1882) |
| | Will-o'-the-Wisp (1883) |
| | Old Cliftonians (1887) |