| Main FC | Yorkshire (1852-1862) |
| | Yorkshire (1863-1866) |
| Other FC | North (1861-1864) |
| | Yorkshire with Stockton-on-Tees (1861) |
| | United England Eleven (1863) |
| | Players (1863) |
| | England (1863-1865) |
| Miscellaneous | Yorkshire (1847) |
| | Bradford (1848-1865) |
| | Leeds (1848-1865) |
| | Stockton (1853-1860) |
| | Wakefield (1857-1864) |
| | All England Eleven (1857-1862) |
| | North Shields (1857) |
| | Grantham (1858-1859) |
| | Hallam and Staveley (1859-1861) |
| | Grange (1859) |
| | Sleaford (1859-1861) |
| | Clydesdale (1859-1866) |
| | York (1860) |
| | West Bromwich (1860) |
| | Colts and Professionals (1860) |
| | Bishop Auckland and District (1860) |
| | Northumberland Club (1860-1864) |
| | Caledonian Club (1860-1861) |
| | Walsall (1861) |
| | HE Handley's Team (1861) |
| | Yorkshire (1861) |
| | Captain Handley's Team (1861) |
| | Lincolnshire (1861-1862) |
| | Sheffield Shrewsbury Club (1861-1864) |
| | Gainsborough (1861) |
| | Middlesbrough (1861) |
| | Sheffield York Club (1862) |
| | Rossall School and Old Boys (1862) |
| | Morley (1862) |
| | South Yorkshire (1862) |
| | Cirencester (1862-1864) |
| | Batley (1862) |
| | Sheffield Collegiate (1862) |
| | Scarborough (1862-1864) |
| | Harrogate (1862-1863) |
| | Pudsey (1863-1864) |
| | Gomersal (1863) |
| | Birkenshaw (1863) |
| | United England Eleven (1863) |
| | Halifax (1863-1864) |
| | Northern Club (1863) |
| | Dewsbury (1863-1864) |
| | Redditch (1863) |
| | Longsight (1863-1865) |
| | Ashton-under-Lyne (1863-1865) |
| | Retford (1863-1865) |
| | Hull (1863) |
| | Stockton and Middlesbrough (1863) |
| | Newcastle upon Tyne (1863) |
| | Alnwick (1863) |
| | Accrington (1864) |
| | Todmorden (1864) |
| | West of Scotland (1865) |
| | Manchester (1865) |
| | Ossett (1865-1866) |
| | Rochdale (1865) |
| | Burton-on-Trent (1865) |
| | Bootle (1865) |
| | Carlisle (1865) |
| | Bradford Colts (1866) |
| | Horncastle (1866) |
| | St Ives (1866) |
| | Oldham (1866) |
| | Dudley (1866) |
| | Redcar (1866) |
| | Darlington (1866) |
| | Keighley (1866) |
| | Stoke-on-Trent (1866) |
| | Mansfield (1866) |
| | Shropshire (1866) |