| Main FC | Oxford University (1869-1872) |
| | Middlesex (1870-1879) |
| Other FC | Gentlemen of the South (1871-1879) |
| | Gentlemen (1871-1876) |
| | Single (1871) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1871-1884) |
| | South (1871-1879) |
| | Gentlemen of Marylebone Cricket Club (1871) |
| | Gentlemen of England (1873-1878) |
| | I Zingari (1877-1884) |
| Miscellaneous | Harrow School (1866-1867) |
| | Incogniti (1866-1869) |
| | Harrow Wanderers (1867-1871) |
| | Monmouthshire (1868) |
| | Breconshire (1868) |
| | Fly-by-Nights (1868) |
| | Shropshire (1868) |
| | S Pelham's XI (1869) |
| | Oxford University Freshmen (1869) |
| | Oxford University Next XVI (1869) |
| | Perambulators (1869-1872) |
| | Oxford University (1869-1872) |
| | Brasenose College, Oxford (1869-1873) |
| | FGB Ponsonby's XI (1869) |
| | Old Harrovians (1869-1872) |
| | Butterflies (1869-1872) |
| | Gentlemen of Shropshire (1869) |
| | B Pauncefote's XI (1870) |
| | Harlequins (1870-1880) |
| | Southgate (1870-1877) |
| | WH Hadow's XI (1871-1872) |
| | Marylebone Cricket Club (1871-1888) |
| | I Zingari (1871-1881) |
| | Old Etonians and Old Harrovians (1871) |
| | West Kent (1871) |
| | RA FitzGerald's XI (1872) |
| | WG Grace's XI (1872) |
| | Middlesex (1873) |
| | Free Foresters (1873) |
| | Gentlemen to Canada Touring Team (1873) |
| | Blackdown (1873) |
| | Bar (1874-1876) |
| | Warnham Court (1876) |
| | New Forest Rangers (1876) |
| | England XI (1877) |
| | Orleans Club (1879) |
| | Crichel (1880) |
| | Esher (1881) |
| | New Forest (1881) |
| | Edinburgh (1886) |