| Main FC | Nottinghamshire (1843-1861) |
| Other FC | Players of Nottinghamshire (1842) |
| | England (1844-1849) |
| | North (1844-1857) |
| | Nottingham (1848) |
| Miscellaneous | Players of Nottinghamshire (1845) |
| | Oxford University Northern Counties (1846) |
| | Oxford University Second XI (1847-1857) |
| | Oxford University (1847-1848) |
| | Old Etonians (1847) |
| | All England Eleven (1847-1857) |
| | Burton-on-Trent (1848-1861) |
| | Oxfordshire (1849) |
| | Earl of Stamford's XI (1854-1857) |
| | Stourbridge (1854) |
| | Scotland (1854) |
| | Nottingham Commercial Club (1855) |
| | Players Engaged at Oxford University (1856-1859) |
| | Stoke-on-Trent (1856) |
| | Nottinghamshire (1857) |
| | Wakefield (1857) |
| | Walsall (1859) |
| | Nottingham (1860) |