| Main FC | Cambridge University (1863-1866) |
| Other FC | Gentlemen of Marylebone Cricket Club (1864-1872) |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1865-1873) | |
| Gentlemen (1866) | |
| Miscellaneous | Westminster School (1858-1859) |
| I Zingari (1859-1879) | |
| Captain Handley's Team (1861-1862) | |
| Cirencester (1862) | |
| Cambridge University Next XVIII (1863) | |
| Cambridge University (1863-1866) | |
| Quidnuncs (1864-1871) | |
| Swallowfield (1865) | |
| Scotland (1865) | |
| Free Foresters (1865) | |
| AH Winter's XI (1866) | |
| Marylebone Cricket Club (1866-1875) |