| Main FC | Yorkshire (1861-1862) |
| | Yorkshire (1863-1870) |
| Other FC | Yorkshire and Durham (1858) |
| | United England Eleven (1859-1869) |
| | North (1859-1870) |
| | Players (1863) |
| | England (1863) |
| | Cambridgeshire and Yorkshire (1864) |
| | United North of England Eleven (1870-1871) |
| Miscellaneous | Leeds (1852-1867) |
| | Bradford (1853-1859) |
| | Holbeck (1856) |
| | York (1856) |
| | Wakefield (1857) |
| | Leeds Clarence (1857) |
| | Stockton (1857) |
| | North Shields (1857) |
| | Richmond (1857) |
| | Whitehaven (1858) |
| | Hovingham (1858) |
| | United England Eleven (1859-1868) |
| | Birkenhead Park (1859) |
| | Rochdale (1859) |
| | All England Eleven (1859-1869) |
| | Stockton-on-Tees (1863) |
| | TW Hornby's North of England XI (1863) |
| | English Eleven (1864) |
| | Middlesbrough (1865) |
| | King's Lynn (1866) |
| | Newark (1866) |
| | Halifax (1867-1868) |
| | Malton (1868) |
| | Edinburgh (1869) |
| | Yorkshire (1869) |
| | Lichfield (1869) |
| | United North of England Eleven (1870-1873) |
| | Wiltshire (1874) |