| 3 | KP Pietersen | Australia v England | 2005 | itt2 |
| 3 | MD Shanaka | England v Sri Lanka | 2021 | itt1175 |
| 2 | RT Ponting | England v Australia | 2005 | itt2 |
| 2 | MEK Hussey | England v Australia | 2005 | itt2 |
| 2 | ME Trescothick | Australia v England | 2005 | itt2 |
| 2 | SPD Smith | England v Australia | 2020 | itt1095 |
| 2 | SPD Smith | England v Australia | 2020 | itt1097 |
| 2 | DJ Malan | Sri Lanka v England | 2021 | itt1175 |
| 2 | HV Patel | England v India | 2022 | itt1616 |
| 2 | AK Markram | England v South Africa | 2022 | itt1717 |