| 4 | HE Hammond | Derbyshire v Sussex | 1946 | f17236 |
| 4 | RG Lumb | Glamorgan v Yorkshire | 1978 | f32173 |
| 4 | JD Love | Kent v Yorkshire | 1980 | f33079 |
| 4 | PWG Parker | Yorkshire v Sussex | 1987 | f37130 |
| 4 | RJ Blakey | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire | 1988 | f37647 |
| 3 | JG Langridge | Derbyshire v Sussex | 1946 | f17236 |
| 3 | AC Revill | Sussex v Derbyshire | 1946 | f17236 |
| 3 | AE Fagg | Derbyshire v Kent | 1947 | f17596 |
| 3 | JH Hampshire | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire | 1975 | f30670 |
| 3 | PN Kirsten | Yorkshire v Derbyshire | 1978 | f32052 |
| 3 | HP Cooper | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1978 | f32052 |
| 3 | CS Cowdrey | Yorkshire v Kent | 1980 | f33079 |
| 3 | G Boycott | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1983 | f34670 |
| 3 | MA Lynch | Yorkshire v Surrey | 1985 | f35860 |
| 3 | K Sharp | Surrey v Yorkshire | 1985 | f35860 |
| 3 | MA Holding | Yorkshire v Derbyshire | 1986 | f36385 |
| 3 | CEB Rice | Yorkshire v Nottinghamshire | 1986 | f36483 |
| 3 | A Walker | Yorkshire v Northamptonshire | 1989 | f38228 |
| 3 | AA Metcalfe | Northamptonshire v Yorkshire | 1989 | f38228 |
| 3 | AP Grayson | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1994 | f41247 |
| 3 | KM Curran | Yorkshire v Northamptonshire | 1995 | f41762 |
| 3 | D Byas | Northamptonshire v Yorkshire | 1995 | f41762 |