| 4 | LJ Fletcher | Yorkshire v Nottinghamshire | 2016 | a24845 |
| 3 | G Boycott | Surrey v Yorkshire | 1975 | a1459 |
| 3 | AA Metcalfe | Lancashire v Yorkshire | 1988 | a5773 |
| 3 | JER Gallian | Yorkshire v Nottinghamshire | 1998 | a11300 |
| 3 | NJ Llong | Yorkshire v Kent | 1999 | a12050 |
| 3 | RJ Cunliffe | Yorkshire v Gloucestershire | 2001 | a13706 |
| 3 | AZ Lees | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire | 2016 | a24845 |
| 3 | TH David | Yorkshire v Surrey | 2021 | a28459 |