| 4 | SA Marsh | British Universities v Kent | 1998 | a11167 |
| 3 | APE Knott | Combined Universities v Kent | 1976 | a1629 |
| 3 | DL Bairstow | Combined Universities v Yorkshire | 1980 | a2649 |
| 3 | AG Davies | Sussex v Combined Universities | 1985 | a4411 |
| 3 | AN Aymes | Combined Universities v Hampshire | 1995 | a9212 |
| 3 | TMB Bailey | Hampshire v British Universities | 1998 | a11131 |