| 4 | WR Smith | Surrey v Nottinghamshire | 2006 | tt460 |
| 4 | AD Hales | Yorkshire v Nottinghamshire | 2020 | tt8913 |
| 4 | PWA Mulder | Nottinghamshire v Leicestershire | 2022 | tt11014 |
| 3 | J Allenby | Essex v Leicestershire | 2006 | tt459 |
| 3 | AB de Villiers | India v South Africa | 2009 | tt1304 |
| 3 | ML Turner | Nottinghamshire v Derbyshire | 2013 | tt3742 |
| 3 | MJ Lumb | Durham v Nottinghamshire | 2014 | tt4358 |
| 3 | TT Bresnan | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire | 2014 | tt4410 |
| 3 | SR Hain | Nottinghamshire v Warwickshire | 2016 | tt5716 |
| 3 | MH Wessels | Essex v Nottinghamshire | 2016 | tt5876 |
| 3 | WMH Rhodes | Nottinghamshire v Warwickshire | 2021 | tt9643 |
| 3 | Shaheen Shah Afridi | England v Pakistan | 2021 | tt9824 |
| 3 | AD Hales | Northern Superchargers Men v Trent Rockets Men | 2021 | tt9860 |
| 3 | SJ Croft | Nottinghamshire v Lancashire | 2022 | tt10876 |
| 3 | JL du Plooy | Nottinghamshire v Derbyshire | 2022 | tt11019 |
| 3 | AJ Turner | Nottinghamshire v Durham | 2023 | tt12313 |
| 3 | AD Hales | Leicestershire v Nottinghamshire | 2023 | tt12415 |
| 3 | DR Mousley | Nottinghamshire v Warwickshire | 2024 | tt13903 |