| 4 | DJG Sales | Worcestershire v Northamptonshire | 2008 | tt924 |
| 4 | DKH Mitchell | Northamptonshire v Worcestershire | 2014 | tt4454 |
| 3 | MCJ Ball | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | 2004 | tt83 |
| 3 | CJL Rogers | Warwickshire v Northamptonshire | 2007 | tt692 |
| 3 | EJH Eckersley | Northamptonshire v Leicestershire | 2014 | tt4341 |
| 3 | WTS Porterfield | Northamptonshire v Warwickshire | 2014 | tt4419 |
| 3 | SP Crook | Durham v Northamptonshire | 2016 | tt5763 |
| 3 | TJ Wells | Northamptonshire v Leicestershire | 2017 | tt6409 |
| 3 | EG Barnard | Northamptonshire v Worcestershire | 2018 | tt7066 |
| 3 | WR Smith | Northamptonshire v Durham | 2018 | tt7118 |
| 3 | TB Sole | Worcestershire v Northamptonshire | 2019 | tt8110 |