| 6 | JM Bairstow | Sri Lanka A v England Lions | 2011 | a21474 |
| 5 | APE Knott | Northamptonshire v Kent | 1969 | a253 |
| 5 | AD Shaw | Northamptonshire v Glamorgan | 1999 | a12079 |
| 5 | TMB Bailey | Middlesex v Northamptonshire | 2002 | a14297 |
| 5 | CM Gazzard | Northamptonshire v Somerset | 2003 | a15254 |
| 5 | GL Brophy | Kent v Northamptonshire | 2004 | a15902 |
| 5 | SJ Adshead | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | 2004 | a16035 |