| 5 | DJG Sales | Essex v Northamptonshire | 2007 | a18390 |
| 4 | G Cook | Glamorgan v Northamptonshire | 1972 | a753 |
| 4 | RJ Lee | Northamptonshire v Oxford University | 1973 | a895 |
| 4 | J Boiling | Northamptonshire v Durham | 1995 | a9368 |
| 4 | SM Katich | Northamptonshire v Hampshire | 2003 | a15195 |
| 4 | DJG Sales | Surrey v Northamptonshire | 2011 | a21469 |
| 4 | JMR Taylor | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | 2015 | a24222 |
| 4 | NJ Selman | Northamptonshire v Glamorgan | 2021 | a28466 |
| 4 | GH Rhodes | Northamptonshire v Leicestershire | 2021 | a28523 |