| 5 | W Rhodes | Australia v England | 1905 | t86 |
| 5 | JT Ikin | South Africa v England | 1951 | t336 |
| 5 | ASM Oakman | Australia v England | 1956 | t428 |
| 5 | GS Sobers | England v West Indies | 1966 | t605 |
| 4 | WG Grace | Australia v England | 1888 | t30 |
| 4 | FA Iredale | England v Australia | 1899 | t63 |
| 4 | GE Gomez | England v West Indies | 1950 | t323 |
| 4 | JE McConnon | Pakistan v England | 1954 | t389 |
| 4 | PNF Mansell | England v South Africa | 1955 | t410 |
| 4 | RB Simpson | England v Australia | 1961 | t510 |
| 4 | IT Botham | Australia v England | 1981 | t907 |
| 4 | RA Harper | England v West Indies | 1988 | t1100 |
| 4 | NV Knight | West Indies v England | 1995 | t1301 |
| 4 | PD Collingwood | West Indies v England | 2007 | t1835 |
| 4 | AN Cook | West Indies v England | 2007 | t1835 |
| 4 | LRPL Taylor | England v New Zealand | 2008 | t1876 |
| 4 | JE Root | Pakistan v England | 2016 | t2208 |
| 4 | TB de Bruyn | England v South Africa | 2017 | t2268 |
| 4 | BA Stokes | South Africa v England | 2017 | t2268 |