| 4 | G Sharp | Surrey v Northamptonshire | 1974 | a1275 |
| 4 | KR Brown | Northamptonshire v Middlesex | 1988 | a5707 |
| 4 | GD Sandford | Huntingdonshire v Bedfordshire | 1999 | a11891 |
| 4 | JA Knott | Cheshire v Bedfordshire | 2003 | a15271 |
| 3 | TJ Yardley | Glamorgan v Northamptonshire | 1981 | a3018 |
| 3 | G Sharp | Worcestershire v Northamptonshire | 1982 | a3416 |
| 3 | DL Bairstow | Northamptonshire v Yorkshire | 1984 | a4089 |
| 3 | RC Russell | Bedfordshire v Gloucestershire | 1985 | a4487 |
| 3 | P Whitticase | Northamptonshire v Leicestershire | 1989 | a6098 |
| 3 | RJ Rollins | Northamptonshire v Essex | 1995 | a9281 |
| 3 | RJ Warren | Indians v Northamptonshire | 1996 | a9863 |
| 3 | RJ Blakey | Bedfordshire v Yorkshire | 2001 | a13560 |
| 3 | IS Spencer | Bedfordshire v Cheshire | 2003 | a15271 |