| 6 | AJ Webbe | Players v Gentlemen | 1877 | f2046 |
| 5 | FGJ Ford | Marylebone Cricket Club v Cambridge University | 1888 | f3271 |
| 5 | NE Haig | Nottinghamshire v Middlesex | 1928 | f12439 |
| 5 | L Hutton | Gentlemen v Players | 1952 | f19704 |
| 5 | RO Butcher | Australians v Middlesex | 1981 | f33579 |
| 5 | ME Trescothick | Middlesex v Somerset | 2013 | f54940 |