| 4 | APF Chapman | West Indies v England | 1928 | t175 |
| 4 | SPD Smith | England v Australia | 2019 | t2362 |
| 4 | MM Ali | India v England | 2021 | t2433 |
| 3 | G Giffen | England v Australia | 1893 | t40 |
| 3 | W Rhodes | Australia v England | 1909 | t105 |
| 3 | JWHT Douglas | Australia v England | 1912 | t129 |
| 3 | WR Hammond | West Indies v England | 1928 | t175 |
| 3 | WR Hammond | Australia v England | 1934 | t237 |
| 3 | WJ Edrich | New Zealand v England | 1949 | t317 |
| 3 | ED Weekes | England v West Indies | 1950 | t326 |
| 3 | JH Wardle | Pakistan v England | 1954 | t390 |
| 3 | R Benaud | England v Australia | 1961 | t511 |
| 3 | TW Graveney | West Indies v England | 1966 | t609 |
| 3 | LR Gibbs | England v West Indies | 1973 | t725 |
| 3 | MF Kent | England v Australia | 1981 | t908 |
| 3 | GA Gooch | New Zealand v England | 1986 | t1051 |
| 3 | MD Moxon | Pakistan v England | 1987 | t1079 |
| 3 | IT Botham | West Indies v England | 1991 | t1175 |
| 3 | RS Dravid | England v India | 2002 | t1614 |
| 3 | GC Smith | England v South Africa | 2008 | t1885 |
| 3 | PD Collingwood | South Africa v England | 2008 | t1885 |
| 3 | MJ Clarke | England v Australia | 2015 | t2178 |
| 3 | BA Stokes | South Africa v England | 2017 | t2266 |
| 3 | Z Crawley | Australia v England | 2023 | t2515 |