| 6 | G Griffith | Gentlemen of the South v Players of Surrey | 1863 | f1241 |
| 6 | GP Thorpe | Kent v Surrey | 1998 | f43726 |
| 5 | F Burbidge | Players v Gentlemen | 1858 | f1058 |
| 5 | FW Wright | Surrey v Oxford University | 1865 | f1324 |
| 5 | VE Walker | Surrey v Middlesex | 1865 | f1337 |
| 5 | EG Hayes | London County v Surrey | 1901 | f5511 |
| 5 | FH Gillingham | Surrey v Essex | 1919 | f9342 |
| 5 | H Ashton | Surrey v Cambridge University | 1922 | f10250 |
| 5 | FH Vigar | Surrey v Essex | 1951 | f19131 |
| 5 | WS Surridge | Lancashire v Surrey | 1955 | f20855 |
| 5 | D Wilson | Surrey v Yorkshire | 1969 | f27849 |
| 5 | Azhar Mahmood | Worcestershire v Surrey | 2006 | f49386 |
| 5 | TWM Latham | Nottinghamshire v Surrey | 2023 | f61646 |