| 6 | KL Gibson | Derbyshire v Essex | 1911 | f8244 |
| 5 | TM Russell | Kent v Essex | 1899 | f5187 |
| 5 | H Strudwick | Essex v Surrey | 1904 | f6297 |
| 5 | J Humphries | Essex v Derbyshire | 1905 | f6572 |
| 5 | RA Boddington | Essex v Lancashire | 1921 | f10087 |
| 5 | FT Summers | Essex v Worcestershire | 1926 | f11529 |
| 5 | WH Livsey | Essex v Hampshire | 1928 | f12393 |
| 5 | R Booth | Essex v Worcestershire | 1964 | f25419 |
| 5 | RW Taylor | Essex v Derbyshire | 1970 | f28362 |
| 5 | EW Jones | Essex v Glamorgan | 1975 | f30701 |