| 4 | AM Lilley | Nottinghamshire v Leicestershire | 2021 | tt9829 |
| 4 | TH David | Leicestershire v Lancashire | 2022 | tt10921 |
| 4 | MGA Finan | Nottinghamshire v Leicestershire | 2023 | tt12370 |
| 3 | HH Dippenaar | Lancashire v Leicestershire | 2008 | tt913 |
| 3 | WI Jefferson | Leicestershire v Nottinghamshire | 2008 | tt975 |
| 3 | GP Smith | Lancashire v Leicestershire | 2013 | tt3741 |
| 3 | TJ Wells | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | 2013 | tt3760 |
| 3 | DKH Mitchell | Leicestershire v Worcestershire | 2014 | tt4368 |
| 3 | SJ Croft | Leicestershire v Lancashire | 2014 | tt4433 |
| 3 | TJ Wells | Warwickshire v Leicestershire | 2017 | tt6359 |
| 3 | AM Lilley | Warwickshire v Leicestershire | 2019 | tt8037 |
| 3 | DJ Vilas | Leicestershire v Lancashire | 2020 | tt8896 |
| 3 | BWM Mike | Leicestershire v Yorkshire | 2023 | tt12296 |
| 3 | PWA Mulder | Northamptonshire v Leicestershire | 2023 | tt12391 |
| 3 | KL Aldridge | Leicestershire v Durham | 2025 | tt15207 |
| 3 | CG Harrison | Leicestershire v Nottinghamshire | 2025 | tt15313 |
| 3 | R Ahmed | Yorkshire v Leicestershire | 2025 | tt15517 |