| 6 | PA Nixon | Essex v Leicestershire | 1994 | a8703 |
| 5 | RW Tolchard | Lancashire v Leicestershire | 1974 | a1112 |
| 5 | SMH Kirmani | Zimbabwe v India | 1983 | a3682 |
| 5 | DL Bairstow | Leicestershire v Yorkshire | 1985 | a4390 |
| 5 | GW Humpage | Leicestershire v Warwickshire | 1988 | a5651 |
| 5 | NR Mongia | Zimbabwe v India | 1999 | a11918 |