| 4 | AW Greig | Pakistan v England | 1974 | t742 |
| 4 | GA Hick | Pakistan v England | 1992 | t1192 |
| 4 | DA Warner | England v Australia | 2019 | t2357 |
| 3 | AW Nourse | England v South Africa | 1912 | t124 |
| 3 | WJ Edrich | New Zealand v England | 1949 | t314 |
| 3 | AJ Watkins | India v England | 1952 | t351 |
| 3 | GS Ramchand | England v India | 1952 | t351 |
| 3 | GAR Lock | Australia v England | 1953 | t375 |
| 3 | DB Close | India v England | 1959 | t476 |
| 3 | R Illingworth | Australia v England | 1972 | t701 |
| 3 | HJ Howarth | England v New Zealand | 1973 | t724 |
| 3 | GS Chappell | England v Australia | 1975 | t762 |
| 3 | BM McMillan | England v South Africa | 1994 | t1264 |
| 3 | MA Atherton | Pakistan v England | 1996 | t1331 |
| 3 | GS Blewett | England v Australia | 1997 | t1373 |
| 3 | ME Waugh | England v Australia | 1997 | t1373 |
| 3 | V Sehwag | England v India | 2002 | t1613 |
| 3 | RS Dravid | England v India | 2002 | t1613 |
| 3 | V Sehwag | England v India | 2002 | t1613 |
| 3 | SP Fleming | England v New Zealand | 2004 | t1702 |
| 3 | AN Cook | South Africa v England | 2012 | t2051 |
| 3 | GC Smith | England v South Africa | 2012 | t2051 |
| 3 | IR Bell | New Zealand v England | 2013 | t2089 |
| 3 | BKG Mendis | England v Sri Lanka | 2016 | t2203 |