| 6 | P Holmes | Nottinghamshire v Yorkshire | 1921 | f10046 |
| 5 | E Lockwood | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1880 | f2340 |
| 5 | TS Pearson | Yorkshire v Middlesex | 1881 | f2438 |
| 5 | W Bates | Middlesex v Yorkshire | 1887 | f3181 |
| 5 | F Lee | Lancashire v Yorkshire | 1889 | f3401 |
| 5 | J Tunnicliffe | Warwickshire v Yorkshire | 1904 | f6471 |
| 5 | S Haigh | Hampshire v Yorkshire | 1911 | f8329 |
| 5 | W Rhodes | Northamptonshire v Yorkshire | 1914 | f9177 |
| 5 | JF Crapp | Yorkshire v Gloucestershire | 1949 | f18506 |