| 5 | FWD Quinton | Yorkshire v Hampshire | 1896 | f4544 |
| 5 | H Smith | Yorkshire v Gloucestershire | 1914 | f9214 |
| 5 | R Booth | Yorkshire v Worcestershire | 1960 | f23447 |
| 5 | RJ Blakey | Leicestershire v Yorkshire | 1994 | f41180 |
| 4 | A Bairstow | Essex v Yorkshire | 1900 | f5433 |
| 4 | G Gaukrodger | Yorkshire v Worcestershire | 1909 | f7804 |
| 4 | A Wood | Indians v Yorkshire | 1932 | f13968 |
| 4 | PA Gibb | Yorkshire v Scotland | 1938 | f16344 |
| 4 | MD Fenner | Yorkshire v Combined Services | 1954 | f20574 |
| 4 | B Taylor | Yorkshire v Essex | 1961 | f23752 |
| 4 | JG Binks | Somerset v Yorkshire | 1963 | f24777 |
| 4 | KM Krikken | Yorkshire v Derbyshire | 1992 | f39960 |
| 4 | RJ Blakey | Northamptonshire v Yorkshire | 1993 | f40596 |
| 4 | RJ Blakey | Northamptonshire v Yorkshire | 1993 | f40596 |