| 6 | J Tunnicliffe | Hampshire v Yorkshire | 1901 | f5681 |
| 5 | WG Grace | A Shaw's Australian Team v England XI | 1885 | f2960 |
| 5 | FWD Quinton | Yorkshire v Hampshire | 1896 | f4544 |
| 5 | GR Cox | Yorkshire v Sussex | 1919 | f9453 |
| 5 | DB Close | Essex v Yorkshire | 1961 | f23752 |
| 5 | MD Moxon | Derbyshire v Yorkshire | 1987 | f37023 |
| 5 | D Byas | Durham v Yorkshire | 1995 | f41834 |