| 5 | GL Jessop | Lancashire v Gloucestershire | 1906 | f6907 |
| 5 | GL Jessop | Nottinghamshire v Gloucestershire | 1909 | f7691 |
| 5 | GA Stannard | Gloucestershire v Sussex | 1919 | f9345 |
| 4 | WG Grace | Kent v Gloucestershire | 1890 | f3502 |
| 4 | W Gunn | Gloucestershire v Nottinghamshire | 1894 | f4034 |
| 4 | AO Jones | Gloucestershire v Nottinghamshire | 1904 | f6344 |
| 4 | NVC Turner | Gloucestershire v Nottinghamshire | 1909 | f7691 |
| 4 | EG Dennett | Northamptonshire v Gloucestershire | 1909 | f7697 |
| 4 | GAT Vials | Gloucestershire v Northamptonshire | 1909 | f7697 |
| 4 | J Seymour | Gloucestershire v Kent | 1914 | f9157 |