| 7 | RW Taylor | Glamorgan v Derbyshire | 1966 | f26456 |
| 6 | H Elliott | Worcestershire v Derbyshire | 1931 | f13530 |
| 6 | H Elliott | Middlesex v Derbyshire | 1932 | f13895 |
| 6 | AC Smith | Derbyshire v Warwickshire | 1970 | f28208 |
| 6 | WK Hegg | Derbyshire v Lancashire | 1995 | f41913 |
| 6 | DJ Pipe | Derbyshire v Worcestershire | 2005 | f48619 |
| 6 | TJ New | Derbyshire v Leicestershire | 2009 | f51627 |
| 6 | SM Davies | Bangladeshis v England Lions | 2010 | f52438 |
| 6 | SO Dowrich | Derbyshire v West Indians | 2017 | f57974 |