| 6 | G Millman | Warwickshire v Nottinghamshire | 1961 | f23908 |
| 5 | RT Spooner | Gloucestershire v Warwickshire | 1951 | f19229 |
| 5 | J Jordan | Warwickshire v Lancashire | 1957 | f21722 |
| 5 | DG Ufton | Warwickshire v Kent | 1962 | f24220 |
| 5 | AC Smith | Lancashire v Warwickshire | 1962 | f24415 |
| 5 | AC Smith | Somerset v Warwickshire | 1964 | f25257 |
| 5 | AC Smith | Nottinghamshire v Warwickshire | 1965 | f25790 |
| 5 | DL Murray | Nottinghamshire v Warwickshire | 1972 | f29289 |
| 5 | DL Murray | Nottinghamshire v Warwickshire | 1974 | f30133 |
| 5 | RW Tolchard | Warwickshire v Leicestershire | 1975 | f30673 |