| 4 | EW Pooley | Australians v United Eleven | 1882 | f2512 |
| 4 | SC Griffith | Gloucestershire v Sussex | 1949 | f18254 |
| 4 | HG Davies | Sussex v Glamorgan | 1950 | f18779 |
| 3 | HR Butt | Hampshire v Sussex | 1908 | f7488 |
| 3 | NC Tufnell | Sussex v Cambridge University | 1910 | f7991 |
| 3 | HR Butt | Warwickshire v Sussex | 1911 | f8335 |