| 4 | GR Cox | Warwickshire v Sussex | 1911 | f8335 |
| 4 | MA Sutton | Sussex v Oxford University | 1946 | f17176 |
| 4 | EDR Eagar | Sussex v Hampshire | 1947 | f17568 |
| 4 | HW Parks | Oxford University v Sussex | 1947 | f17580 |
| 4 | JG Langridge | Oxford University v Sussex | 1948 | f17968 |
| 4 | JG Langridge | Worcestershire v Sussex | 1949 | f18265 |
| 4 | AJ Watkins | Sussex v Glamorgan | 1950 | f18779 |
| 3 | GE Palmer | United Eleven v Australians | 1882 | f2512 |
| 3 | FR Spofforth | Lord March's XI v Australians | 1886 | f3020 |
| 3 | W Bruce | Lord March's XI v Australians | 1886 | f3020 |
| 3 | AE Relf | Cambridge University v Sussex | 1910 | f7991 |
| 3 | FT Mann | Sussex v Cambridge University | 1910 | f7991 |
| 3 | J Bailey | Sussex v Hampshire | 1946 | f17167 |
| 3 | G Cox | Hampshire v Sussex | 1946 | f17167 |
| 3 | AWH Mallett | Sussex v Oxford University | 1947 | f17580 |
| 3 | C Oakes | Oxford University v Sussex | 1947 | f17580 |
| 3 | B Boobbyer | Sussex v Oxford University | 1950 | f18768 |
| 3 | JG Langridge | Glamorgan v Sussex | 1950 | f18779 |