| 4 | AJ Finch | Durham v Yorkshire | 2014 | tt4431 |
| 3 | JJB Lewis | Nottinghamshire v Durham | 2003 | tt1 |
| 3 | LRPL Taylor | Leicestershire v Durham | 2010 | tt1763 |
| 3 | AG Botha | Durham v Warwickshire | 2010 | tt1817 |
| 3 | PD Collingwood | Derbyshire v Durham | 2014 | tt4411 |
| 3 | SG Borthwick | Nottinghamshire v Durham | 2016 | tt5733 |
| 3 | JJ Cobb | Durham v Northamptonshire | 2017 | tt6315 |
| 3 | JTA Burnham | Northamptonshire v Durham | 2019 | tt7970 |
| 3 | L Trevaskis | Leicestershire v Durham | 2020 | tt8979 |
| 3 | JJ Bushnell | Yorkshire v Durham | 2022 | tt10990 |