| 5 | MJ Di Venuto | Durham v Derbyshire | 2001 | f45972 |
| 5 | R Clarke | Durham v Warwickshire | 2012 | f54061 |
| 4 | TR Ward | Durham v Kent | 1995 | f41764 |
| 4 | W Larkins | Somerset v Durham | 1995 | f41870 |
| 4 | NH Fairbrother | Durham v Lancashire | 1996 | f42450 |
| 4 | BL Hutton | Durham v Middlesex | 2006 | f49372 |
| 4 | A Lyth | Durham v Yorkshire | 2011 | f53261 |
| 4 | PD Collingwood | Middlesex v Durham | 2015 | f56499 |
| 4 | LS Livingstone | Durham v Lancashire | 2016 | f57116 |