| 6 | MA Garnham | Warwickshire v Essex | 1991 | f39330 |
| 6 | CMW Read | Essex v Nottinghamshire | 2010 | f52479 |
| 6 | JS Foster | Gloucestershire v Essex | 2014 | f55687 |
| 5 | GR Stephenson | Essex v Hampshire | 1974 | f30100 |
| 5 | GR Stephenson | Essex v Hampshire | 1978 | f32107 |
| 5 | APE Knott | Essex v Kent | 1985 | f35817 |
| 5 | MA Garnham | Somerset v Essex | 1993 | f40534 |
| 5 | RJ Rollins | Leicestershire v Essex | 1995 | f41717 |
| 5 | RJ Rollins | Nottinghamshire v Essex | 1996 | f42497 |
| 5 | KJ Piper | Essex v Warwickshire | 1997 | f43215 |
| 5 | MG Croy | West Indians v New Zealand A | 2000 | f45167 |
| 5 | BJ Hyam | Worcestershire v Essex | 2000 | f45199 |
| 5 | JS Foster | Derbyshire v Essex | 2006 | f49516 |
| 5 | JS Foster | Hampshire v Essex | 2010 | f52370 |
| 5 | LD Sutton | Essex v Lancashire | 2010 | f52391 |
| 5 | JS Foster | Glamorgan v Essex | 2015 | f56467 |
| 5 | AL Davies | Essex v Lancashire | 2017 | f57855 |
| 5 | MS Pepper | Kent v Essex | 2019 | f59484 |
| 5 | AJA Wheater | Middlesex v Essex | 2020 | f60204 |