| 6 | SE Leary | Cambridge University v Kent | 1958 | f22156 |
| 5 | CW Rock | Marylebone Cricket Club v Cambridge University | 1886 | f2985 |
| 5 | H Trumble | Cambridge University v Australians | 1890 | f3487 |
| 5 | CH Eyre | GJV Weigall's XI v Cambridge University | 1904 | f6308 |
| 5 | GRJ Roope | Cambridge University v Surrey | 1980 | f33027 |
| 5 | KP Dutch | Cambridge University v Middlesex | 2000 | f45114 |