| 4 | CAR Coleman | Derbyshire v Leicestershire | 1930 | f13242 |
| 4 | DB Carr | Oxford University v Derbyshire | 1961 | f23798 |
| 3 | AE Alderman | Lancashire v Derbyshire | 1935 | f15043 |
| 3 | CS Elliott | Lancashire v Derbyshire | 1949 | f18364 |
| 3 | CA Milton | Derbyshire v Gloucestershire | 1952 | f19784 |
| 3 | GM Emmett | Derbyshire v Gloucestershire | 1952 | f19784 |
| 3 | PD Watts | Derbyshire v Northamptonshire | 1962 | f24408 |
| 3 | MJK Smith | Derbyshire v Warwickshire | 1966 | f26334 |
| 3 | EJ Barlow | Lancashire v Derbyshire | 1976 | f31227 |
| 3 | FC Hayes | Derbyshire v Lancashire | 1976 | f31227 |
| 3 | NH Fairbrother | Derbyshire v Lancashire | 1984 | f35301 |